My Home Wizard Blogs

The Top 4 Watering Cans for 2023: Tried and Analyzed

Maintaining healthy plants, whether indoors or in your garden, necessitates a reliable watering can. Jen Stark, an experienced gardener, interior designer, home improvement specialist, and founder of Happy DIY Home, emphasizes the importance of assessing the handle when considering a watering can. As you’ll be carrying, holding, and maneuvering it frequently, a comfortable grip is crucial. “The handle should be sizable enough for a secure hold and might even feature finger slots,” Stark advises.
Our comprehensive study delved into the most popular watering cans available and acquired 32 different sizes and styles for rigorous testing at HQ in Gulf Shores, AL. During these trials, we filled the cans using both sink and hose sources, pouring water into various pots, including hanging ones, of different sizes and designs. We evaluated the cans’ construction by subjecting them to drops from four feet onto both solid surfaces like concrete and softer ones like grass, documenting any damage incurred. Ratings were then assigned based on criteria such as design, ease of use, efficiency, size, resilience, and value. The resulting list showcases our preferred models that excelled across diverse tests.

The Wizard Picks

Best Overall: Behrens 2.5 Gallon Metal Watering Can
Best Small: HB Design Co Wood Handle Watering Can (Minimalist)
Best Splurge: Modern Sprout Tall Brass Watering Can
Best for Outdoors: XXXFlower Watering Can at Amazon

1. Best Overall: Behrens 2.5 Gallon Metal Watering Can

Our Ratings

  • Design 5/5
  • Effectiveness 4/5
  • Ease of Use 5/5
  • Size 5/5
  • Durability 5/5


  • Dual handles offering versatile hand positioning
  • Exceptional durability
  • Adjustable flow
  • Effortless refilling


  • Less practical for hanging plants

The Behrens 2.5 Gallon Metal Watering Can emerged as the frontrunner for its classic design, user-friendliness, durability, and value. It stands as an ideal choice for varied watering needs. Its robust construction ensures prolonged utility, even surviving a four-foot drop without cracks or spillage. The innovative dual-handle design, including a hinged handle, enables effortless maneuvering and minimizes strain on hands and wrists. Its 2.5-gallon capacity facilitates watering multiple plants without frequent refilling, while the lightweight galvanized metal design ensures hassle-free transportation. However, it may pose challenges for watering hanging plants.

Price at the time of publication: $42

2. Best for Small Spaces: HB Design CO Wood Handle Watering Can

Our Ratings

  • Design 4/5
  • Effectiveness 4.5/5
  • Ease of Use 5/5
  • Size 5/5
  • Durability 4/5


  • Sleek and stylish profile
  • Steady pour with extended reach
  • Comfortable handle


  • Risk of splashing due to open top
  • Wooden handle’s vulnerability outdoors

The Terrain Beech Wood Handle Watering Can excels for those tending to petite houseplants. Its aesthetically pleasing, open-top design delivers consistent pouring and features a handle conducive to comfortable gripping. Despite its small size, it’s suitable for filling in bathroom or kitchen sinks. However, the wooden handle is better suited for indoor use due to potential outdoor damage. Despite minor dents during drop tests, its price aligns with its quality and distinctive appearance.

Price at the time of publication: $25

3. Best High-End Choice: Modern Sprout Tall Copper Watering Can

Our Ratings

  • Design 4.5/5
  • Effectiveness 5/5
  • Ease of Use 4.5/5
  • Size 5/5
  • Durability 3/5


  • Elegant appearance
  • Available in multiple sizes
  • Effortless carrying, filling, and pouring


  • Limited outdoor suitability
  • Incompatible with delicate plants

The Williams-Sonoma Tall Copper Watering Can stands as a luxurious selection, combining aesthetics with functionality. Its stunning hammered texture adds a touch of opulence, and its effectiveness is undisputed. While suitable for various plant heights and easy to handle, its drop test on concrete revealed structural weaknesses. While its radiant exterior requires maintenance, its charm and pour accuracy make it a worthy splurge, particularly for plant enthusiasts seeking dual-purpose decor.

Price at the time of publication: $109

4. Best for Outdoor Use: XXXFlower Watering Can

Our Ratings

  • Design 4/5
  • Effectiveness 4/5
  • Ease of Use 5/5
  • Size 4/5
  • Durability 4/5


  • Sprinkle and pour options
  • Adjustable nozzle direction
  • Ergonomic handles
  • Fill hole cap for protection


  • Less visually appealing than other options

The XXXFlower Watering Can stands out with distinctive features that enhance its performance. Its dual-handle design ensures ergonomic comfort, catering to both carrying and hanging flower baskets. Despite its generous capacity, it remains compact and is easily fillable in standard sinks. A unique swiveling spout provides versatility in watering styles. Moreover, a protective cap prevents splashing and critter intrusion. It effectively withstands drops and proves efficient for garden plant care.

Price at the time of publication: $19

The Wizards Conclusion

Behrens 2.5 Gallon Metal Watering Can takes the top spot with its exceptional design, ease of use, and durability. For those seeking a premium option, the HB Design CO Tall Brass Watering Can offers both elegance and functionality. Each watering can on this list caters to specific needs, ensuring ample options for nurturing your plants.

Testing Methodology for Watering Cans

To thoroughly assess the performance and functionality of various watering cans, we embarked on a comprehensive testing process. Our approach involved rigorous evaluation of 32 different watering cans, spanning diverse styles and sizes. These cans were procured for examination at HQ, situated in Gulf Shores, Alabama. The testing process encompassed a range of scenarios to ensure a holistic assessment.

  1. Ease of Use Evaluation:

We examined the ease of use by filling the watering cans using both sink faucets (for smaller cans) and garden hoses (for larger cans). To verify the claimed water capacity, we measured the volume of water each can could hold. We conducted a walking test while carrying full watering cans for at least 30 feet, observing any design features that facilitated carrying and maneuvering, such as dual handles or ergonomic grips. Spillage or sloshing of water within the can was also noted.

  1. Effectiveness Testing:

To gauge the effectiveness of the watering cans, we watered plants in varying sizes of pots and hanging baskets. We observed the accuracy and control of water streams in both pouring and sprinkle modes (if applicable). The maneuverability of each can based on its size was taken into account. The precision of the water stream was especially significant for plants located in challenging positions or obstructed by foliage.

  1. Durability Assessment:

Recognizing that watering cans are often exposed to outdoor elements or dropped, we subjected each design to durability testing. This involved dropping the cans from a height of four feet onto concrete and grass surfaces. Any resulting dents, scratches, or leaks were documented, offering insights into the resilience of each watering can design.

  1. Value Rating:

We assessed the value proposition of each watering can, considering its performance and features in relation to its price. The evaluation was conducted impartially, with the price only revealed after the testing process had concluded.

  1. Editor Selection:

Upon completion of the testing rounds, our team of editors selected the standout watering cans based on their performance and suitability for various purposes. Detailed product descriptions were crafted, enriched with performance insights to guide potential buyers in making informed decisions.

Key Features to Consider in a Watering Can

  1. Capacity:

Choose a watering can size that matches your plant collection’s needs. Larger plants or numerous plants may require a higher-capacity can to avoid frequent refilling, while indoor plants or hanging baskets might benefit from smaller cans.

  1. Balance and Grip:

Seek a watering can with good balance and grip to prevent tipping and ensure easy handling, even when full. Look for well-designed handles and ergonomic features.

  1. Spout Type:

Consider the type of spout that suits your watering preferences. Free-flow spouts are ideal for precise aiming, while rose spouts provide a gentle sprinkle for delicate plants. Opt for adjustable spouts for versatility.

  1. Material:

Choose a material that suits your usage environment. Plastic is lightweight and durable, suitable for outdoor use. Metal options like galvanized steel or copper offer durability and aesthetics. Ceramic cans are better for indoor display due to their fragility.

  1. Ease of Filling:

Ensure the watering can is easy to fill, especially for indoor options. Check if the handle allows convenient filling without obstruction from the faucet.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. How do you clean a watering can?

Regular rinsing suffices for most cases, but for mineral deposits, use a solution of distilled white vinegar and warm water. Let it sit, scrub, and rinse. Soak the rose attachment if clogged.

  1. What’s the best watering can for indoor plants?

Choose a smaller-capacity can with a longer, thin spout for precision. A can like the HB Design Co Indoor Watering Can fits this profile well.

  1. How do you select a watering can?

Base your choice on the intended use, whether indoors or outdoors, and the capacity needed. Consider balance, grip, spout type, and material for a well-rounded decision.

Ready to elevate your plant care game with the best watering can for 2023? 

Let our experts take over! 

Visit us here to be in touch with us!

More from My Home Wizard

2023 All Rights Reserved.